Tesla has aggressively pursued legal action against critics in China, targeting car owners, bloggers, and media outlets that question the safety and quality of its vehicles. The company has won nearly all its lawsuits, benefiting from strong government backing and China’s pro-business legal environment. Tesla’s legal victories highlight the growing influence of foreign firms in China’s judicial system, where consumers and critics face significant challenges in holding corporations accountable.

Zhang Yazhou’s Case: A Battle Against Tesla

One of Tesla’s most widely publicised legal disputes in China involves Zhang Yazhou, a car owner who became a vocal critic of the company. The case dates back to February 2021, when Zhang’s father was driving their Tesla Model 3 in Henan province and allegedly experienced brake failure, leading to a crash. While local traffic police attributed the incident to speeding and driver error, Zhang insisted that the car’s brakes had malfunctioned. She demanded full access to the crash data, but Tesla refused to provide it in its entirety, further fueling her suspicions.

Zhang’s Protest & Tesla’s Response

In April 2021, frustrated by Tesla’s refusal to disclose complete data, Zhang staged a high-profile protest at the Shanghai Auto Show. She climbed onto the roof of a Tesla car, wearing a T-shirt that read “Tesla brake failure”, and shouted slogans, drawing widespread media attention. The protest went viral on Chinese social media, sparking heated debates about Tesla’s reliability and corporate ethics.

(more…)